Anthony conveniently (though, in his defense, also accidentally) left out the fact that they were arguing at the time and were really pissed off at eachother. "I don't know," he shrugged. He didn't actually care that much about this whole thing, he just thought it was weird how differently Gabriel acted with them. "I think he just hates me." He didn't really know how to respond to Elijah's declaration of not going to church again. So he just chose to kind of keep quiet about it.