Anthony eventually chose to give Elijah the benefit of the doubt, here, and just stayed silent and didn't bring up what he knew. It took a few moments until he was comfortable enough to actually relax, but it happened. His skepticism and fear hadn't just vanished, of course, he just chose to put it aside this one time. "Good night," he said, before realizing that it almost certainly wasn't night. He really could not comprehend the passage of time, right now. "or day. Whatever. I don't know."